Skip to content
en

Proton Mail vs Carbonio

Proton Mail sends account or support data outside Europe. Carbonio has no verified data location.

The same facts for each tool. Highlighted rows differ.
FactProton MailSwitzerlandCarbonioItaly
Who can reach your data (Differs)Level 3 of 5Account or support data leaves EuropeNot verifiedNo public source says where the data sits.
How European the company is (Differs)97 of 10072 of 100, provisional
Legal entityProton AG, registered in Switzerland30 of 30 pointsZextras S.r.l., registered in Italy30 of 30 points
Ownership and control (Differs)European control30 of 30 pointsNo controlling owner identified20 of 30 points
OperationsHeadquarters in Europe (Geneva)15 of 15 pointsHeadquarters in Europe (Milano)15 of 15 points
Data residency (Differs)Stored in Europe by default15 of 15 pointsNot verifiedNo evidence, 0 of 15 points
OpennessOpen core7 of 10 pointsOpen core7 of 10 points
ReviewAI reviewedAI reviewed
Badge (Differs)Badge: eligibleBadge: not eligible

Features

Features as the vendor's own pages state them, each with its source. Features never change the score or the level.

Features
FeatureProton MailCarbonio
Free planYesproton.me/mail/pricingYeszextras.com/carbonio-community-edition
Works in the browserYesproton.me/mail/pricingYesdocs.zextras.com/carbonio-ce/html/install/post-install/web-access.html
Mobile appiOS, Androidproton.me/mail/pricingiOS, Androiddocs.zextras.com/user-guides/carbonio/en/html/mobile_apps/toc.html
Desktop appWindows, macOS, Linux (Paid plans)proton.me/mailNot verified
Use your own domainPaid plansproton.me/mail/pricingYesdocs.zextras.com/carbonio-ce/html/adminpanel/domains/newdomain.html
Email aliasesYesproton.me/mail/pricingYesdocs.zextras.com/carbonio-ce/html/admincli/management/managealias.html
IMAP/SMTP access for other mail appsPaid plansproton.me/support/imap-smtp-and-pop3-setupYesdocs.zextras.com/carbonio-ce/html/install/requirements.html
Import mail from another providerYesproton.me/mail/pricingYesdocs.zextras.com/carbonio-ce/html/admincli/migration.html
Server-side filters and rulesYesproton.me/support/email-inbox-filtersYesdocs.zextras.com/carbonio-ce/html/adminpanel/cos.html
Automatic out-of-office replyPaid plansproton.me/mail/pricingYesdocs.zextras.com/carbonio-ce/html/adminpanel/cos.html
Scheduled sendingYesproton.me/support/schedule-email-sendNot verified
Undo sendNot verifiedNot verified
CalendarYesproton.me/mail/pricingYeszextras.com/carbonio-community-edition
Encrypted email to people on other providersYesproton.me/mail/pricingNot verified
Shared mailboxesNot verifiedNot verified
Built-in AI assistantPaid plansproton.me/mail/pricingNot verified
Two-factor sign-inYesproton.me/support/two-factor-authentication-2faPaid planszextras.com/editions
Single sign-on (SAML)Not verifiedPaid planszextras.com/editions
Public APINot verifiedYesdocs.zextras.com/carbonio-ce/html/develop/toc.html
Export your dataYesproton.me/support/export-emails-import-export-appYesdocs.zextras.com/carbonio-ce/html/adminpanel/cos.html
CalDAV/CardDAV syncNot verifiedNot verified
OpenPGP encryption built inYesproton.me/support/how-to-use-pgpNot verified
No ads in the mailboxNot verifiedNot verified
Free trialNot verifiedNot verified
Paid plans fromUS$4.99 per account a monthproton.me/mail/pricingNot verified
Can be self-hostedNot verifiedYeszextras.com/carbonio
WebhooksNot verifiedNot verified
Automation (Zapier, Make, n8n)Not verifiedNot verified
MCP server for AI assistantsNot verifiedNot verified
End-to-end encryptionYesproton.me/mail/pricingPaid planszextras.com/features

Subprocessors

SubprocessorsProton MailCarbonio
Atlassianparent in United States (Differs)Account and support dataNot listed
Chargebeeparent in United States (Differs)Account and support dataNot listed
PayPalparent in United States (Differs)Account and support dataoptionalNot listed
Stripeparent in United States (Differs)Account and support dataNot listed
Zendeskparent in United States (Differs)Account and support dataNot listed

Compare other tools